A deep dive into SEVENTEEN's discography PART 4 : Al1 : kpopthoughts

A deep dive into SEVENTEEN’s discography PART 4 : Al1 : kpopthoughts

Quoted from the primary publish:

My overview publish construction goes like this:

I’ll overview the tracks, write about how I really feel about it briefly, then give a grade which ranges as follows: S, A, B, C, D and F. S being the songs I like essentially the most, F being songs I just like the least.

For even higher understanding, this is how I rank songs.

S – Songs which can be wonderful, and I can hearken to all day, or can join with it emotionally.

A – Songs which can be wonderful, however I do not join with it as a lot as I do with S tier songs.

B – Songs that I like, nevertheless it is not one thing I would search to hearken to myself.

C – Songs which can be okay, I am simply impartial with the track.

D – Songs that I do not like.

F – Songs that I dislike with a ardour and do not assume I’ll ever like this unironically.

Discover how I write “what I like essentially the most to the least” and never “the perfect to worst”?

How I grade on the songs is a mixture of my subjective opinion and the way it objectively is, however a lot, rather more in the direction of my subjective opinion. I have no idea many phrases about music manufacturing so I can’t give a full fledged correctly goal overview, and that is simply executed for enjoyable, I am not right here to be a wannabe music critic, I am simply right here to discover new music and have enjoyable listening and produce ideas 😀

After that I’ll write how I really feel concerning the album general and depart some brief ideas. Then there shall be a desk displaying all of the songs I’ve reviewed of the group categorised in tiers. The songs might go up (or down) as I write posts as a result of some songs do age very well.


PART 1 – 17 Carat / Boys Be

PART 2 – Love & Letter (+ repackage)

PART 3 – Going Seventeen


Al1 Hyperlink to spotify

1.Do not Wanna Cry

The track is the definition of a common track. Plenty of Kpop followers would know what comes after the pre-chorus and the “울고 싶지 않아” then each member does all these tremendous exhausting impossible-to-follow dances.

In my view the track is ideal. The beat drop may be very The Chainsmokers-ish, nevertheless the verses are FAR extra fascinating. The association is superior. I’ve to offer it an S only for how effectively it sounds and the way Seventeen efficiently creates one other signature sound of them other than the funky sound they’ve.

Tier : S


I just like the slowness of the track and the feelings it provides, nevertheless I believe this falls underneath these sort of songs the place I must be within the temper to hearken to this. Anyhow, the vocals sound good right here. The refrain is impactful, the verses are okay. Total, I prefer it, however not that a lot. That is fascinating as a result of I often like vocal-centric songs essentially the most.

Tier : B

3.IF I

The “if i if i if i” refrains are actually catchy. I actually benefit from the instrumental right here and the refrain (or the shortage thereof) really matches the track. It is empty makes the track sound “lonely” if I can not discover a higher phrase to explain. The melody(?) can also be catchy. Plenty of the weather right here aren’t issues I might search for in a track however collectively they sound nice.

Tier : A

4.Swimming Idiot

The whistle-like sounds at first already says I am gonna like this. It is such a therapeutic summer season track, with its feel-good ambiance. The deep voice saying “Swimming idiot” took me off guard slightly although, I want it was just a few member saying that as a substitute, however I get pleasure from that instrumental so much.

If I’ve to be over-critical, the one gripe I’ve in the direction of the track is that the track would not actually go wherever, not essentially a foul factor, particularly when it is only a stress-free track that does not take itself severely.

Tier : S

5.My I

The beat sounds barely tropical. I do not actually really feel the verses, however the refrain actually shines right here. The “my i-i-i” is extraordinarily catchy.

I want there is a bridge rather than that brief instrumental break. Similar to Swimming Idiot, this track feels prefer it would not actually go wherever, however this does not precisely really feel like a chilling track both so I want it had one thing extra.

Tier : A

6.Loopy In Love

The track sounds good proper from the beginning, the refrain is nice and actually has vitality in it. The bridge brings in some fascinating sounds. I just like the track however to not the extent of the opposite tracks right here. There’s one thing off about this track that I can not precisely pinpoint what it’s..

I can also’t cease pondering of the Beyoncé track when seeing this track’s identify, and because of this, unintentionally evaluate this track to that lol.

Tier : B


Total Ideas:

It’s one other strong mini album from Seventeen, no unhealthy apples, nevertheless I really feel like there aren’t many standout moments from this album both other than the title observe. All of the songs listed here are well-done, therefore the great rankings, but it looks like there’s one thing off in nearly all of the songs that is stopping me from absolutely having fun with it, besides DWC and Swimming Idiot. I am gonna assume it is due to my music style, however then I nonetheless get pleasure from their different EDM songs. Perhaps the drastic change on this album threw me off guard after listening to Going Seventeen? Perhaps the songs on this album will develop into large growers in a while?

The album after this can be a full one, “Teen, Age”, and its repackage Director’s Reduce. I’ll overview each in the identical publish as a result of it is mainly the identical album however with just a few extra tracks added. I love Clap so perhaps I will find yourself liking extra tracks there in comparison with this album.


Total Rating (Tier):

– Songs in daring are the songs reviewed on this publish.

– Songs with brackets and numbers subsequent to them point out that they’ve modified tiers, and what number of tiers did it went up or down. After listening increasingly more, some songs do age effectively, and turns into higher as I pay attention, some songs sadly do not and will get uninteresting over time, songs that are not in S tier could have an opportunity to go up, or down over time.

Tier Songs
S 20, Mansae, Very Good, Therapeutic, SIMPLE, Chuck, Fairly U, Say Sure, Spotlight, Do not Pay attention In Secret, Smile Flower**,** Adore U, Love Letter, Do not Wanna Cry, Swimming Idiot
A House, Hit Tune, Adore U (Vocal Group), Lovely, Growth Growth, Lean On Me, Quick Tempo, I Do not Know**,** Nonetheless Lonely, If I, My I
B Once I Develop Up, Drift Away, Monday to Saturday (Hiphop Group), Behavior, Loopy In Love
C Shining Diamond, Fronting, OMG, Rock
D Jam Jam, No F.U.N
F Ah Yeah, Shining Diamond (Perf. Group)
Author: admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *